Ken Griffey Jr.’s retirement
I was a closet fan (what baseball fan wouldn’t like someone with power (honest power), speed, great defensive ability and a smile on his face) and sure, I played the hell out of his SNES games. But what centerfielders can we compare Ken Griffey Jr. to? I actually think he stands alone, but if I had to say someone…
Having a discussion here: http://operationsports.com/fofc/showthread.php?t=78025
I’d say Duke Snider. Two people have said Joe DiMaggio.
Their statements: Crazy talk. Griffey had twice the career of Duke Snider. Also, Dimaggio doesn’t even approach Griffey unless you give him extra credit for the years he missed during the war. Even with them, It’s pretty even. And I’d give Griffey the bonus for playing in a more difficult era.
As a fellow Yankee fan, I love Joe D. But this era has integration, better scouting, and specialists. It’s much harder to dominate now than it was then. I give all the WW2 players extra credit for the years they missed. But Griffey was a far better player than Snider. I’d also put him equal to Joe D.
My statement: Joe Dimaggio is the 2nd greatest right handed hitter of all time (behind Rogers Hornsby) – you are too busy looking at “total” stats, without diving into the real stats. Dimaggio’s hitting ability and his power/lack of strikeouts, puts Dimaggio’s well above Griffey.
Since, you are so into “total” stats, add 2800 ABs to Duke Snider and see how close he comes to Griffey’s “total” stats. I think the AVG,OBP,SLG, OPS, OPS+ fall in closer with Duke Snider than Joe Dimaggio.
and how is Griffey playing is a “more difficult” era? The expansion era with smaller ball parks?
http://www.baseball-reference.com/players/s/snidedu01.shtml
http://www.baseball-reference.com/players/g/griffke02.shtml
http://www.baseball-reference.com/players/d/dimagjo01.shtml
Filed under: MLB | No Comments »